8/2/2019 | 3 MINUTE READ

Video: How Simulation Assists Directed Energy Deposition

Scrapping an AM part is potentially as costly as scrapping a machined part. Directed energy deposition is an additive process that can benefit from a resource that safeguards machining: simulation software. 


Facebook Share Icon LinkedIn Share Icon Twitter Share Icon Share by EMail icon Print Icon

Directed energy deposition (DED) is a metal additive manufacturing process often applied using a CNC machine tool or a machine that operates much like one. In some cases, technology developed for CNC machines can aid DED as well. The most notable example of this is probably simulation software, a tool for validating the build cycle before it begins. I recently spoke about this with Gene Granata of CGTech and Tim Bell, currently with Siemens, who was with BeAM Machines when this was filmed.


Peter Zelinski, Additive Manufacturing
Directed Energy Deposition (DED) is a metal additive process that delivers metal instead of working within a powder bed. I talked about this with Tim Bell of Siemens who, at the time of this conversation, was with DED machine maker BeAM.

Directed Energy Deposition is a particular type of metal additive process. Describe DED.

Tim Bell, Siemens (formerly with BeAM)
DED is simply taking blown powder or welding wire, feeding it through a nozzle and introducing a power source or energy type to melt the powder wire, create a melt bowl and then apply the melt bowl using G code and a traditional machine tool.

Peter Zelinski  
So, DED is the oldest metal additive process.

Tim Bell  
Historically, we called it cladding. Cladding DED is much older than powder-bed fusion, but hasn't had the fanfare that powder-bed fusion has had.

Peter Zelinski  
So, let's talk about that. It is the oldest metal additive process, not necessarily an unsophisticated process, it's advanced since those cladding days you're describing. Talk about DED today, where the technology has come to today.

Tim Bell  
Sure, and I would say size is number one. I would say there are structural components within gas turbine engines, within the engine, that traditionally are made from large origins and they machine 80% of it and throw it away. And we're not trying to help them work on [whether or not they] can create near net shape with 10% machine left to do. So, I would say those large complex geometries and components that require extensive machining, those are the target parts that people are coming to us with.

With today's technology and more powerful, more accurate lasers and our ability to more accurately project the materials into the the power source, the energy source, now we can create really refined depositions. You know, we have deposition accuracies in a plus or minus 4,000 range.

Peter Zelinski  
Is there a type of part or type of application where DED is stronger compared to this other modality of metal additive?

Directed energy deposition: [a] metal additive process that probably most resembles a CNC machine tool. The deposition head is following tool paths [and] deposition paths, similar to a CNC machine. It has a control like a CNC machine tool, and it has five-axis capability. That is not typical of metal additive. We can appreciate the value of five axis in subtractive machining. Talk about the value in additive.

Tim Bell  
The biggest value is you don't need support structures. We just position the BART and we always keep the build normal to the machine. Five axis also gives us the freedom to repair existing components or add features to them. Think of a duct where you would go to a factory and you would see them making flanges and bosses and tubes and they would weld it all to a piece of pipe. Well, you can just mount that piece of pipe into the machine and come in and print all of those flanges because you can access all sides of the component.

Peter Zelinski  
Talk about design rules for DED. What are the kinds of design considerations that are distinctive to this process?

Tim Bell  
That's a tough question. You're limited to your deposition width, right? If you want to do a single wall component, and you have a nozzle that's one millimeter or two millimeter, to build a one and a half millimeter wall, you have to do two steps or you have to do a half spacing with a specific overlap. It all comes around to designing to the deposition width. The design rules are much freer than they are for powder-bed fusion. There's not as many. Our problems are typically thermal-based because of the heat generated for their build envelope.

Peter Zelinski  
Talk about how a foundation in CNC machining helps a manufacturer more quickly adopt DED.

Tim Bell  
Quite simply, they know G code. They know how to come in and set g54. Understanding tool offsets and work coordinate zones and how machines are dynamic — their acceleration, their deceleration, their feed rates — it's all the same.