Aitrtech
Published

3D Printing With Recycled Powders: Reducing Waste and Material Costs

Can you print high-quality parts using recycled thermoplastic powder? JawsTec saves 2 tons of waste per year by investing in SLS printers that reuse scrap to make new parts.

Share

JawsTec acquired four Nexa3D QLS 230 SLS machines to meet its goals of increasing 3D printing capacity while also reducing its overall waste. These machines are able to produce high-quality parts with a mix of new and recycled powder. Source (all photos): JawsTec

To meet sustainability goals, more and more companies are looking for ways to recycle or reuse manufacturing scrap, including the thermoplastic powder left over from 3D printers.

But this also has to be economically feasible in the long term. So unless the 3D printing is done near a facility that can recycle or reuse this material, what is the most sustainable option that will also save money?

For one company, the solution was to invest in 3D printers that could recycle scrap from its other 3D printers to make new components — allowing the company to grow its business, reduce waste to landfill, and save materials costs all in one shot.

JawsTec is a manufacturing service provider in American Falls, Idaho that is, according to co-founder and CEO Oscar Klassen, “mostly focused on polymer 3D printing, with CNC machining as another smaller portion of the business.”

Founded in 2018, the company currently operates 16 industrial 3D printers — including selective laser sintering (SLS) systems from EOS, Multi Jet Fusion (MJF) systems from HP, and, most recently, QLS 230 and QLS 820 SLS machines from Nexa3D.

JawsTec provides services for prototyping through volume production of parts in a range of industries, from components for agriculture and industrial food production to aerospace and automotive prototypes. Among the company’s customers to date are Tesla, Apple, BMW, Ford, Delta and SpaceX.

Klassen says, “We have an instant quoting platform that makes it simple and quick for customers to get into this space and set expectations. We are able to get our customers higher quality parts competitive to those made with injection molding as far as strength and quality, and also cheaper for prototyping and small production runs.”

After achieving initial successes, the company’s main focus became growing its range of machines to accommodate more customers. At the same time, Klassen says that reducing manufacturing scrap — especially the excess powder produced from polymer printers — was a growing concern.

With its legacy SLS and MJF machines, the company had to dispose of up to 30% of its total thermoplastic powder, amounting to more than 2 tons of waste per year that needed to be stored and ultimately shipped to a landfill at JawsTec’s expense.

“This was high-quality, usable powder coming off these machines, but we didn’t have a way to use it,” Klassen says. He notes that while some larger companies may be able to find uses for the material or ship it back to a materials supplier for them to recycle, for smaller companies and service bureaus like JawsTec, recycling waste powder generally isn’t economically feasible.

So, the company had multiple goals when looking for its next machines to invest in: growing JawsTec’s printing capacity, providing an in-house solution for its current powder waste, and saving on disposal costs.

This search led to Nexa3D’s latest QLS 230 machine, a small-format SLS machine developed with the capability of running on either virgin or a combination of virgin and recycled thermoplastic powder.

JawsTec ultimately invested in four of these machines, as well as one larger Nexa3D QLS 820 machine.

Addressing Recycling and Sustainability in 3D Printing

Two Nexa3D QLS 230 printers

The QLS 230 machines at JawsTec’s shop are used to produce small production runs of parts for recreation, automotive or agricultural applications.

The QLS 230 is an open platform, industrial SLS printer with a build volume of 9 x 9 x 9 inches, said to provide 24-hour cycle speeds with one single-watt laser. It is compatible with recycled powders from SLS and MJF printers, as well as a range of virgin thermoplastic materials.

Lewis Simms, chief marketing officer at Ventura, California-based Nexa3D, explains that the machine was developed to provide customers with a “zero-waste” printing option. He says, “Taking waste powder from other printers and leveraging it to make new, good parts is a huge win not only from a sustainability perspective, but from the economics of the process as well, lowering the cost per part. Before coming to Nexa3D I worked at a service bureau, and I know firsthand that thermoplastic powders aren’t inexpensive. So, it’s a double win.”

However, from a supplier perspective, it’s worth noting that developing systems to use more sustainable materials like recycled or bio-based polymers isn’t the only solution being worked on to address sustainability in 3D printing.   

Simms emphasizes that it’s important for 3D printer suppliers to address sustainability not only from a materials perspective — which decreases the carbon footprint for the customers using the printers — but from a systems perspective, or the level of Nexa3D’s own printer manufacturing. “For our own printers, we looked at materials reduction in the printer manufacturing itself. We have printers like our XiP and XiP Pro that are purposefully built from recyclable materials like aluminum, for example, to reduce consumables. Additionally, over 80% of the power is directly for part production. The printer itself is quite energy efficient,” he says.

Recycled Powder SLS in Action

How does a machine like the QLS 230 work in practice for a customer?

Klassen explains that JawsTec is now able to save the excess powder from its other printers, combine this with virgin material — the current ratio is just under 80/20 new powder to recycled — and print new parts for customers.

The ratio of new to recycled powder was an initial trial and error process, as JawsTec aimed to use as much recycled material as possible without sacrificing part quality. “If you were to use only recycled powder without adding any virgin material at all, the part would become very fragile, almost like paper, and would just crack and break,” Klassen says. “At this 80/20 ratio, we’re seeing high-quality parts coming off the machine.”

The smaller build volume of the machine — compared to for example 13.7 x 13.7 x 15.7 inch build volume for JawsTec’s QLS 820 — combined with its relatively lower-power laser and recycled material content suit it for prototyping or small production runs.

3D printed shoe
3D printed ball with Nexa3D logo on it

These demonstrator parts showcase the complexity and range of the systems.

Another benefit to the printer is fast printing cycles. Simms explains, “The printer is geared for about a 24-hour total cycle time, meaning you’re able to turn around a build per day including cooldown, which means it’s a much shorter cooldown time than you typically see with SLS, thanks in part to the smaller build volume. In comparison, most SLS printers can take up to several days per build just to cool down.”

Klassen adds, “These machines would be good on their own, because you can use new powder in them, too, but it’s especially beneficial when you pair them with existing machines that you can recycle powder from.”

JawsTec is able to sell parts produced with the QLS 230 for a lower price — “we’re getting the recycled material at no cost, so that’s less material cost we have to factor into the pricing, and that makes it very competitive, especially for customers who may be new to 3D printing and wanting to try it out for the first time,” Klassen says.

According to Simms, “A lot of sustainability initiatives come at a higher cost to the company. A solution like this enables a company to lower its carbon footprint while also benefiting its own business financially.”

End markets this has been used for include the recreational market, including parts for RC cars, as well as some automotive and agriculture customers. “It really depends on what the end goal is, be it a part with the highest possible strength or lowest possible cost, or made with sustainable materials. This is the printer we use when a customer prioritizes low part costs and sustainability,” Simms says.

So far, the company says it has saved more than 2 tons of powder from landfill, while reaching its capacity goals and nearly doubling production output.

Simms emphasizes that there’s still much more to be done in the industry to enable truly sustainable manufacturing practices. “We’re making good strides toward putting more sustainable practices in place, but the additive industry has so much farther to go.”

Sustainability Correspondent

Hannah Mason

Hannah Mason reports on sustainability in manufacturing across Gardner Business Media brands.
She is also a Technical Editor reporting about composites manufacturing for CompositesWorld, a topic she has covered since 2018.
She earned a Masters of Arts in professional writing from the University of Cincinnati and a B.A. in writing from West Liberty University.

UPM Additive Solutions
Acquire
Airtech
The World According To
AM Radio
The Cool Parts Show

Related Content

Sustainability

Next-Gen Horse Trailers to Be Built With Robotic 3D Printing

Double D Trailers is currently developing a prototype horse trailer that will be made with large-format additive manufacturing. The technology brings potential benefits for labor, weight and design features to this subset of recreational vehicles.

Read More
LFAM

3D Printing Brings Sustainability, Accessibility to Glass Manufacturing

Australian startup Maple Glass Printing has developed a process for extruding glass into artwork, lab implements and architectural elements. Along the way, the company has also found more efficient ways of recycling this material.

Read More
LFAM

Alquist 3D Looks Toward a Carbon-Sequestering Future with 3D Printed Infrastructure

The Colorado startup aims to reduce the carbon footprint of new buildings, homes and city infrastructure with robotic 3D printing and a specialized geopolymer material.

Read More
Sustainability

Sustainable Furniture Company Model No. Maintains Product Focus with Switch from DIY to Industrial 3D Printers

The startup founded in 2018 has matured in its product offerings as well as its manufacturing equipment, moving from homegrown 3D printers to industrial large-format machines.

Read More

Read Next

IMTS

New Equipment, Additive Manufacturing for Casting Replacement and AM's Next Phase at IMTS 2024: AM Radio #54

Additive manufacturing’s presence at IMTS – The International Manufacturing Technology Show revealed trends in technology as well as how 3D printing is being applied today and where it will be tomorrow. Peter Zelinski and I share observations from the show on this episode of AM Radio. 

Read More
Postprocessing

How Avid Product Development Creates Efficiencies in High-Mix, Low-Volume Additive Manufacturing

Contract manufacturer Avid Product Development (a Lubrizol company) has developed strategies to streamline part production through 3D printing so its engineering team can focus on development, design, assembly and other services. 

Read More
Basics

Postprocessing Steps and Costs for Metal 3D Printing

When your metal part is done 3D printing, you just pull it out of the machine and start using it, right? Not exactly. 

Read More
Airtech International Inc.