Staying Focused on the Promise of AM
For this company, realizing that promise is a long-term undertaking. In the short term, it involves sometimes saying no.
I saw a great mentor/protégé moment during my visit to Imperial Machine & Tool, an established machining business now earning 5 percent of its sales from additive production work done on two machines from SLM Solutions. Christian Joest, part of this shop’s owning family, was concerned about a situation that would concern any manufacturing business leader: Valuable machines—specifically, the two metal AM machines—were sitting idle. There was opportunity to put them to work. He openly wondered: Why not use the availability on these machines to serve companies wanting basic metal 3D printing work, such as prototype parts?
Chris Joest, Christian’s father and Imperial’s president, had a simple answer. He said, “It’s not what we do.” To him, the promise of additive manufacturing is not prototypes, not short-term work, but ongoing production. In fact, the promise is production of new components that can’t be made any other way. Staying focused on that promise is important, he says, even if that promise is slow to be realized, and even if it takes time and commitment to help customers develop this kind of work.
I see the younger man’s point. Imperial has been, and still is, a machining business. The old adage says your machine tool isn’t making money if it’s not making chips. Similarly, a 3D printer isn’t making money if it’s not making layers. On either type of machine, there is a good argument for taking the work you can get.
But then—and this has taken me longer—I can now see the father’s point as well. Indeed, this point applies to more than manufacturing. Whatever you have, it also has you, and whatever you do, it is doing something to you. Every step aims at a destination, so where do you want to go?
Consider this: If Imperial were to go down the road of doing one-off 3D printing work (worthwhile work, to be sure), then that would mean entering relationships with customers wanting this work. It would mean becoming connected to these companies, and making and keeping promises to them. And though there is nothing wrong in any of this, all of it together would divert the company from seeking the work it wants. It would leave the company potentially too distracted to commit when the opportunity for that work presents itself, or even too distracted to notice when the first glimpse of that opportunity appears.
The phrase “addition by subtraction” describes something real. What we leave out enhances the effectiveness of what remains. And increasingly, I wonder if this isn’t the most powerful form of addition there is. For the organization or the individual with something of real worth to offer, there are many opportunities. There are many things to which to say yes. And saying yes produces an effect—it leads to activity, variety and the answers to pressing needs.
But Chris Joest’s point is this: The way into some kind of next-level success involves a different answer. It involves saying no. Indeed, the way forward—far forward—entails learning how and when to say no, and coming to recognize just how surprisingly often this answer is the right one.
Related Content
Multimaterial 3D Printing Enables Solid State Batteries
By combining different 3D printing processes and materials in a single layer, Sakuu’s Kavian platform can produce batteries for electric vehicles and other applications with twice the energy density and greater safety than traditional lithium-ion solutions.
Read MoreWhat Does Additive Manufacturing Readiness Look Like?
The promise of distributed manufacturing is alluring, but to get there AM first needs to master scale production. GKN Additive’s Michigan facility illustrates what the journey might look like.
Read MoreNew Electric Dirt Bike Is Designed for Molding, but Produced Through 3D Printing (Includes Video)
Cobra Moto’s new all-electric youth motocross bike could not wait for mold tooling. Parts have been designed so they can be molded eventually, but to get the bike to market, the production method now is additive manufacturing.
Read MoreDMG MORI: Build Plate “Pucks” Cut Postprocessing Time by 80%
For spinal implants and other small 3D printed parts made through laser powder bed fusion, separate clampable units resting within the build plate provide for easy transfer to a CNC lathe.
Read MoreRead Next
Metal 3D Printing in a Machine Shop? Ask the Marines
A hybrid system combining metal 3D printing with machining gives the Marine Corps perhaps its most effective resource yet for obtaining needed hardware in the field. It also offers an extreme version of the experience a machine shop might have in adding metal AM to its capabilities.
Read MoreLearning Curve
A manufacturer that has succeeded for three generations expects additive manufacturing to be part of the reason why it will succeed in the fourth. One year into its investment in the technology, here is the company’s experience so far.
Read MoreHybrid Additive Manufacturing Machine Tools Continue to Make Gains (Includes Video)
The hybrid machine tool is an idea that continues to advance. Two important developments of recent years expand the possibilities for this platform.
Read More